Honest Comparison
Both tools are built for TCG stores. They take very different approaches to pricing, sales channels, and what you pay. Here's a straight look at what each one does — so you can pick the right fit.
Inventory, automated daily pricing, POS, and optional Shopify sync for Magic, Pokémon, and Riftbound — for both stores and serious collectors. Flat all-inclusive tiers with no per-sale commission. Works with or without Shopify. Canadian-owned, Canadian pricing (CAD).
A mature, store-focused platform (now part of TCGplayer) with cloud POS, kiosk mode, buylist automation, an events/ticketing module, and multi-channel selling across a Shopify storefront, eBay, and TCGplayer. Requires a Shopify plan and charges a per-sale commission on online orders. Built for stores only, priced in USD.
| CardUpkeep | BinderPOS | |
|---|---|---|
| Magic: The Gathering support | ✓ Yes | ✓ Yes |
| Pokémon TCG support | ✓ Yes | ✓ Yes |
| Riftbound support | ✓ Yes | Not confirmed |
| Works without Shopify | ✓ Yes — Shopify optional | ✗ Shopify plan required |
| Automated pricing | ✓ Included in every paid tier | ✓ Yes (TCGplayer data) |
| Per-sale commission on online orders | ✓ None | 2% website / 2.5% via TCGplayer |
| Flat all-inclusive pricing | ✓ Yes — one price per tier | Subscription + commission + Shopify |
| Canadian pricing (CAD) | ✓ Yes — no USD FX | USD pricing |
| POS (point-of-sale) system | ✓ Yes | ✓ Yes |
| In-store kiosk mode | Not confirmed | ✓ Yes |
| Events / ticketing module | ✗ No | ✓ Yes |
| Multi-marketplace sync (eBay, TCGplayer) | ✗ Shopify only | ✓ Yes (TCGplayer US only) |
| Buylist automation | ✓ Yes | ✓ Yes |
| Store credit ledger | ✓ Yes | ✓ Yes |
| Collector / personal use tier | ✓ Yes — from $9.99/mo | ✗ Store-focused only |
| Public online storefront (buy cards from home) | ✓ Yes — every plan, including free | ✓ Yes (Shopify-based) |
| Free tier available | ✓ Yes — Copper (1,000 cards) | ✗ Paid plans only |
CardUpkeep data reflects current live features. BinderPOS data sourced from their public site (binderpos.com) and TCGplayer's seller documentation — verify current details there, as terms and fees change. "Not confirmed" means the feature was not found on their public site at time of writing; it does not necessarily mean the feature doesn't exist. Last checked: July 2026.
CardUpkeep charges one flat price per tier — no commission on your online orders. BinderPOS adds 2% on website sales (2.5% through the TCGplayer integration) on top of your subscription and Shopify's own fees. On steady online volume, that percentage adds up fast.
CardUpkeep bills in CAD with no USD conversion surprises. BinderPOS is priced in USD, so your monthly cost moves with the exchange rate on every renewal.
BinderPOS requires an active Shopify plan to run at all. CardUpkeep works standalone — Shopify sync is there if you want it, but it's optional, not a prerequisite you have to pay for separately.
Riftbound is a first-class game in CardUpkeep alongside Magic and Pokémon — inventory, automated pricing, and Shopify sync included. We haven't confirmed Riftbound support in BinderPOS's public docs.
CardUpkeep has a $9.99/mo Tin tier built for collectors tracking up to 25,000 cards. BinderPOS is built entirely around store operations and doesn't offer a collector-focused plan.
CardUpkeep is built and supported by its founder. When something goes wrong or you need a feature, you're talking to the person who wrote the code.
BinderPOS is likely the stronger choice if your operation leans on multi-channel selling across eBay and the TCGplayer marketplace (US sellers), if you run frequent ticketed events and tournaments and want a built-in events module, or if an in-store customer kiosk is central to your counter experience. It's a mature, well-established platform backed by TCGplayer. Those are genuine strengths we don't match today. If they're central to how your store runs, evaluate both platforms carefully.
Export your existing inventory to CSV and import it directly into CardUpkeep — no re-keying, no starting from scratch. Your Shopify products connect on first sync. If you get stuck, support is one message away.
Start free with up to 1,000 cards — no credit card required. Paid plans from $9.99/mo CAD.
Start free See plans